table of contents
Picking a staffing model isn’t about which one is “best.” It’s about what problem you’re trying to fix this month. A warehouse drowning in holiday orders has a different headache than an office that just lost its only bookkeeper.
Three options, then, and what each one is good for.
Temporary staffing
You need people for a stretch of time, and you know it’ll end. Peak season, a big install project, covering someone on leave, a backlog that has to be cleared before an audit.
The worker stays on our payroll, not yours. Taxes, workers’ comp, W-2s: ours. You tell them what to do and approve the hours.
When the rush dies down, the assignment ends. That’s it. Nobody in your office has to handle a layoff.
Where temp falls short is a job with a long learning curve. If it takes three months to get good at the role, a rotating cast of temps keeps you stuck in training mode.
Temp-to-hire
Think of it as a trial run that pays. The worker shows up on the agency’s payroll, does your real shifts beside your real crew, and at some agreed point you decide: keep them or not.
Interviews are fine, but they mostly show you who’s good at interviews. Three or four weeks on the floor shows you who clocks in at 5:45, figures out the RF scanner by Wednesday and doesn’t fight with the second-shift lead. From the worker’s side, they get to find out if the job matches the posting before they commit.
Ask early how conversion works. Usually there’s a magic number of hours after which you can hire the person for free, plus a buyout if you can’t wait that long. Totally normal. Just don’t learn the number in week six.
We went deeper on this in our post about temp-to-hire staffing in Cypress Creek.
Direct hire
This is for jobs you’re filling for keeps. A maintenance tech, a shift supervisor, the person who’ll run your front office. They go on your payroll from the first day, and losing them would hurt.
Here the agency does the hunting. We find candidates, screen them, call their references and hand you a short list worth your time. You run the interviews and make the call. Once your pick starts, there’s a single placement fee, typically figured off the first year’s pay, and that’s the end of the billing. They work for you.
Basically, you’re paying so you can interview three solid people instead of wading through 200 résumés.
A quick way to decide
Ask yourself two things.
How sure am I that this job will still exist in six months? If you’re not sure, start with temp.
How costly is a bad hire here? If one wrong pick means a missed shipment or a mess in the books, temp-to-hire or a carefully screened direct hire is worth the extra effort.
You can also mix them. Lots of plants around here keep a core crew they hired directly, bring new operators in temp-to-hire, and lean on plain temps when November hits. Nothing’s locked in.
What it costs, roughly
Temp and temp-to-hire are billed hourly, only for hours worked. Direct hire is a single fee. We broke down how those numbers are built in how much a staffing agency charges in Houston, and if you’re comparing against doing it all yourself, see whether it’s cheaper to hire through an agency or directly.
Talk it through with us
We do all three at SpireTek, and for bigger crews we can add payroll services or put a coordinator onsite. The whole menu is on our staffing services page.
Not sure which fits? That’s a normal place to start. Tell us about the opening or call (346) 260-8077, and a recruiter will help you sort it out.
