table of contents
are you looking for a talent to recruit?

discover how we help you!

People use the two terms like they mean the same thing, and there’s real overlap, but the basic difference comes down to whose payroll the worker ends up on and how you pay for the help.

A staffing agency, in the traditional sense, puts workers on its own payroll and sends them to work at your company, billing you by the hour for as long as you need them. A recruiting firm, which some people still call a headhunter, finds candidates for jobs on your payroll, and you pay it a fee once the person is hired.

On the staffing side, the agency is the employer on paper, so it takes care of:

  • paychecks and payroll taxes
  • workers’ comp coverage
  • hiring paperwork like the I-9

Your supervisors run the work itself. The whole setup is built for speed, say fifteen extra pickers by Monday or a few more hands for a six-week project.

You pay an hourly bill rate only for hours worked, and when the need goes away, the assignment ends. We break down that bill rate in how much a staffing agency charges in Houston, and the split of legal responsibilities in who is the employer of record.

How a recruiting firm works

Recruiting firms focus on permanent hires, often for salaried, specialized or senior positions such as engineers, plant managers, controllers or sales leaders, where the search takes longer and the cost of a wrong hire is high. Most work on contingency, meaning they get paid only if you hire their candidate, while some top-level searches are retained, with part of the fee paid upfront. Either way the fee is usually a percentage of the new hire’s first-year salary, and after that the person is simply your employee.

Where the lines blur

Plenty of staffing agencies also do direct-hire placements, which is basically recruiting under another name, and some recruiting firms run a contract or temp division. SpireTek, for instance, offers temporary staffing, temp-to-hire and direct hire, so the same team that fills a forklift order can also run a search for a maintenance supervisor. Temp-to-hire sits right in the middle, starting as staffing and ending as a permanent hire, which we explain in temp, temp-to-hire or direct hire.

Here’s how we’d usually sort it:

  • need people this week, for hourly work that may not last: staffing
  • salaried job you’re filling for years, where fit beats speed: recruiting or direct hire
  • want to keep the person but see them work first: temp-to-hire

If you’re not sure which camp your opening falls into, that’s a perfectly good place to start a conversation. SpireTek has been doing both kinds of work around northwest Houston since 1999; you can tell us about the role or call (346) 260-8077, and we’ll be straight with you about which approach makes the most sense.